CORONAVIRUS (COVID-19) LATEST UPDATES HERE

THE DEATH OF ENTREPRENEURS RELIEF? IF SO, HOW DO WE SECURE IT?

blog header image

Posted : 10 Feb 2020 at 10:34:44
Category: News

Share this article

  • There is a lot of talk about ER being scrapped
  • Our view is that ER will be retained but restricted further
  • Are your clients concerned about a loss of ER? If so, a solution exists.

Introduction

“Reports of my death are greatly exaggerated”

The story goes that this was the text of a cable sent by Mark Twain from London to the US media after his obituary had mistakenly been published.

We have heard a lot over the last few months about the death of Entrepreneurs’ Relief (“ER”). Is this attractive relief a victim of the same exaggeration that Twain suffered?

Of course, ER is one of a long line of capital gains tax reliefs targeted at those either retiring or exiting from a business. Most commonly, ER will apply when a business owner sells his or her shares to a third party or family member.

For the qualifying conditions please see here.

The relief is highly attractive as it provides for a 10% effective rate of tax on the relevant gain.

Each person has a lifetime limit which is currently set at £10m.

What’s the problem?

The main problem is cost.

The Resolution Foundation (suggests that ER ‘costs’ the Government £2.7bn per year. This is more than three times the amount that was originally forecast. Other think tanks have also made the same point.

However, this should not be a surprise.

Firstly, the £10m referred to above was originally set at £1m. As such, the maximum benefit one can receive has potentially increased ten-fold.

Secondly, the ‘cost’ of a tax relief is clearly highly sensitive to the headline rate of CGT.

Originally, the 10% rate compared to a top rate of 18%. In the meantime, we have had a top rate of 28% before this fell in 2016 to 20%.

In addition, a further expansion of the relief applies to those who hold shares in their company which employs them (waiving the 5% requirement) under the EMI scheme has also increased the cost of the relief.

The second issue is that recent surveys undertaken by the Government suggest that ER does not influence behaviour to any great extent.

So, the verdict appears to be that ER is both expensive and relatively pointless. This seems pretty damning, doesn’t it?

What is the future of ER?

Both the Labour Party and the Conservatives made it clear that ER would not survive in its current form.

However, it has been clear policy of successive governments that entrepreneurs should pay a lower rate of tax ton a business sale than, say, if an investor sells Banksy’s latest artwork.

I’m not saying whether this is right policy. But it is a fact.

In 2007/08, its last year of operation, business asset taper relief ‘cost’ the Exchequer £7.8bn. Of course, this makes ER look very good value indeed!

If the Government was to abandon an apparently long-standing commitment to those responsible for business growth it would, in my opinion, send a very negative message to business.

As such, it is my view that ER will be retained but with the qualifying conditions will be restricted further. This might include a tightening of the definition of personal company and perhaps a lengthening of the period for which one must satisfy the conditions.

A further, obvious change might be to cut the £10m lifetime limit.

Securing ER – is there a solution?

I am not one to try and scare people in to action but those concerned about a loss of ER might consider exploring a ‘friendly’ sale before the Budget.

This can be done relatively simply and was a method used by many when it was announced that taper relief would be scrapped over a decade ago (prior to the announcement that ER would succeed the relief).

The solution might be to sell the shares to another vehicle – for example to a family trust – with the completion of that contract being deferred in to the future.

The exchange of contracts should take place before Budget day. This becomes the reference point for CGT purposes meaning that on completion the sale is deemed to have taken place prior to Budget and with ER being banked.

There should be no cash flow issues here and it should be possible to unwind the arrangement if that becomes desirable in the future.

If you or your clients have any queries about ER, or would like to discuss a solution for securing ER, then please reach out to ETC Tax please get in touch.

LATEST SIMILAR NEWS

LOAN CHARGE APPG PUBLISH REPORT THAT EXPOSES FUNDAMENTAL FLAW IN MORSE REVIEW ON THE LOAN CHARGE
Posted on: 19 Mar 2020 at 11:28:52
Loan Charge APPG publish report that exposes fundamental flaw in Morse Review on the Loan ChargeThe All-Party Parliamentary Group on the Loan Charge have today published a comprehensive report which exposes the fundamental flaw in the Government commissioned Morse Review into the Loan Char...
DAVID DAVIS MP: OUR TAX BURDEN IS TOO HIGH. WE NEED A BOLD BUDGET, NOT 'SPREADSHEET SUNAK'
Posted on: 10 Mar 2020 at 10:42:26
The Chancellor should use a bold first Budget to fix idiocies in the tax system, absorb the shock of the coronavirus and get Britain match-fit for Brexit, argues David Davis.Rishi Sunak must be getting used to surprises, first with his sudden appointment as Chancellor, now with the extraordinar...
PAYE OR UMBRELLA: SIDE-STEPPING IR35
Posted on: 04 Mar 2020 at 14:39:33
Published on March 4, 2020Status is onlineAlexander Wilson LL.B. (Hons.) (Dunelm.), CTAIR35 barrister and CTA - Helping all corporations safely retain independent contractors with strong legal adviceKey PointMoving forward on the umbrella or PAYE model exposes the client to the risk of retroact...
CARNEY ADMITS LATEST DECISION TO HOLD INTEREST RATES WAS ‘FINELY BALANCED’
Posted on: 03 Mar 2020 at 13:31:19
Bank of England governor Mark Carney has revealed his last vote as part of the Monetary Policy Committee (MPC) on whether to move the central bank’s base rate was “finely balanced”.Carney noted that despite choosing to hold the Bank Base Rate at 0.75 per cent there were still plenty of reasons...
LAING O’ROURKE TO BUILD EVERTON’S NEW STADIUM
Posted on: 20 Feb 2020 at 10:07:10
Everton Football Club has appointed Laing O’Rourke as preferred contractor for its planned 52,000 capacity stadium at Bramley-Moore Dock on Liverpool’s waterfront.Dan Meis’ brick, steel and glass design takes its inspiration from the historic maritime and warehouse buildings nearbyA pre-construction...
POUND RALLIES AS UK EMPLOYMENT HITS RECORD HIGH AND WAGES BEAT 2008 PEAK
Posted on: 18 Feb 2020 at 13:45:59
Wages beat their pre-financial crisis peak for the first time at the end of 2019, as the level of UK employment rose to a record high of 32.9m people.A total of 180,000 people entered the workforce between October and December 2019, the Office for National Statistics (ONS) said today.Read more:&nbsp...