blog header image

Posted : 04 Mar 2020 at 14:39:33
Category: News

Share this article

  • Published on March 4, 2020

Alexander Wilson LL.B. (Hons.) (Dunelm.), CTA

IR35 barrister and CTA - Helping all corporations safely retain independent contractors with strong legal advice

Key Point

  • Moving forward on the umbrella or PAYE model exposes the client to the risk of retroactive demand for historical PAYE / NIC.

 

Clients (to use the language of the off-payroll legislation) are in many cases deciding to entirely side-step the off-payroll legislation by refusing contracts with PSC's and insisting that workers accept PAYE or umbrella arrangements instead. In some cases, clients are doing this on the back of a Status Determination Statement ('SDS'), which is somewhat otiose.

What does this mean?

The first effect is that the off-payroll legislation is no longer in scope as there is no intermediary; the worker is either an employee of the client (albeit receiving salary through a third-party payroll provider) or an employee of the umbrella company.

Where a company unilaterally declares that going forward contractors previously engaged through their PSC's will be required to agree to umbrella or PAYE models, the contractor is in a 'take it or leave it' position. Whereas IR35 status is determinable on an assessment of the terms of the engagement, if the client insists on (actual) employment, that is what they will get.

So no 'Status Determination Statement' is required (hence, 'otiose'). The client is off the hook. Job done.

Not Quite

Consider ESM0117 (a section from HMRC's Employment Status Manual):

"Where it is agreed that a worker who has previously been regarded as self-employed should now be treated as employed, then you will need to consider whether to pursue the employer for NICs and tax for back years." [Emphasis added].

The danger of retrospective enquiry is that HMRC will look at what the determined status is going forward and seek to apply that going back.

So where a client continues to engage contractors through their PSC's but determines that Chapter 10, Part 2 ITEPA 2003 (the private sector off-payroll legislation) applies going forward, HMRC will expect that Chapter 8 (the old IR35) will have applied in the past. Here, the risk is primarily with the contractor's PSC which was liable for the PAYE and NIC's under Chapter 8.

On the other hand, if the client demands employment going forward (actual employment, not simply deemed 'inside IR35'), then why wouldn't HMRC ask why the engagement was not always an employed one? In that case, Chapter 8 would never have applied and the client would find themselves liable to unpaid PAYE / NIC's.

If HMRC did pursue the contractor's PSC (for example, on the basis that they are an easier target), the contractor's immediate response would be that HMRC should be chasing the client. I could see that as being a very attractive argument in the First-Tier Tribunal (Tax Chamber).

Original Source - LinkedIn - PAYE Umbrella Side Stepping IR35

SIMILAR NEWS

blog header image
NEWS
VAT DOMESTIC REVERSE CHARGE FOR CONSTRUCTION

What is the VAT domestic reverse charge for construction services? The VAT domestic reverse charge for building and construction services, to give it its full title, is a change in how VAT is han ...

blog header image
NEWS
NUMBER OF FIRMS REGISTERED AS VISA SPONSORS PEAKS AS EU IMMIGRATION HITS 15-YEAR LOW

The number of UK businesses registered as sponsors for Tier 2 work visas reached a record high in the last three months of 2019, with 28,734 companies on the Home Office register. This is the highest ...

blog header image
NEWS
SELF-EMPLOYMENT INCOME SUPPORT SCHEME

What you need to know Who can claim: Self-employed individuals or a member of a partnership (as long as certain eligibility criteria are met, see below). Limited companies and trusts are not e ...

blog header image
NEWS
LANDLORDS NEED TO BE PREPARED FOR EVERY POSSIBILITY WITH CGT CHANGES – YOUNG

The age-old question posed by all private sector landlords at any one time is often, ‘what do I do next?’ For most, the answer is staring them in the face, and that continues to hold ...

blog header image
NEWS
TIGHTER SELF-EMPLOYED AND AFFORDABILITY RULES HERE ‘FOR SOME TIME’ – HSBC

Tighter self-employed and affordability rules here ‘for some time’ – HSBC Tightened self-employed lending criteria and affordability rules are seen across the mortgage market since ...

blog header image
NEWS
SNITCHES GET RICHES: HMRC PAYMENTS TO TAX EVASION WHISTLEBLOWERS UP 63% IN 2019/20

HMRC reported a 63% increase in payments to whistleblowers for reporting tax evasion in the 2019/2020 tax year, paying £473,000 to informants during the period.  In the previous tax year HM ...

business-directory Business Directory
smartbusinessdirectory Payroll Services Business Directory
truebusinessdirectory payroll-services Directory
payroll-services Directory