IR35 RULES FOUND TO BE RIDDLED WITH FLAWS AND UNFAIRNESSES
Witnesses told the Finance Bill sub-committee that IR35 rules had left them in a ‘halfway house’: they do not enjoy the rights that come with employment, yet they are considered employees for tax purposes.
“IR35 was conceived 20 years ago. It was a sickly child when it was conceived, and I do not think it has got any better along the way.”
These were the words of Justine Riccomini from the Institute of Chartered Accountants of Scotland (ICAS), to the Finance Bill Sub Committee. She summed up the range of evidence we received from over 700 contractors, businesses and tax specialists during the course of our inquiry.
It’s right that everyone should pay their fair share of tax. But as we set out in our report , Off-payroll working: treating people fairly, the IR35 rules—the Government’s framework to tackle tax avoidance by those in ‘disguised employment’—have never worked satisfactorily, throughout the whole of their 20-year history.
Ignoring IR35’s troubled past, the Government had planned to extend the off-payroll working rules to the private sector in April 2020. These rules build on IR35, and the proposals were designed to mirror similar rules implemented in the public sector in 2017. As the Committee heard from numerous witnesses, this is despite parts of the public sector reacting in 2017 by making 'blanket assessments' that groups of contractors were within the rules –in order to avoid challenges from HMRC.
The Covid-19 crisis, and the Government’s sensible judgement that introducing these rules would be dangerous at such a difficult time for the economy, mean that the implementation of the rules will be deferred for a year. But kicking these problems down the road will not make them go away.
The Committee of course welcomed the Government’s decision to defer: the reforms were always likely to make the labour market sick. But the Government now needs to think again about the whole IR35 framework if it believes businesses recovering from the worst crisis since the Second World War will be prepared to take on this burden in just 12 months’ time.
Our inquiry found the rules to be riddled with flaws and unfairnesses. The Government has overlooked the potential impact on the wider labour market, and particularly the gig economy. The Committee also heard that many companies were already making blanket status determinations and laying off contractors in anticipation of the implementation of these new rules, despite their delay.
Witnesses also told the Committee that the rules had left them in a ‘halfway house’: they do not enjoy the rights that come with employment, yet they are considered employees for tax purposes. In short, they are “zero-rights employees”. This flies in the face of the recommendations in the Government-commissioned Taylor Review: that taxation of labour should be made more consistent across different forms of employment, while at the same time the rights and entitlements of self-employed people should be improved.
I hope the Government takes the opportunity afforded by this unexpected delay to fundamentally reconsider its proposals. It should ensure that there’s a fair balance between tax, rights and risk. Contractors already concerned by the economic uncertainty of coronavirus now have the added worry of paying more in employment taxes and having their fees cut by clients – despite no increase in their rights or entitlements. The Committee urges the Government to go back to the drawing board and consider the fairer alternatives that we lay out in our report.
Lord Forsyth is a Conservative peer and chair of the Lords finance bill sub-committee.
Original source - Politics Home
IR35 CHANGES IN APRIL 2021 (AGAIN)
The IR35 changes in the private sector previously scheduled for April 2020, will go ahead on 6 April 2021 The Government has now published the Finance Act which contains the final text of the off-payr ...
CHANGES ON HIRING EU WORKERS DECEMBER 31ST
CHANGES ON HIRING EU WORKERS DECEMBER 31ST Have you seen the latest news with regards to the changes to hiring workers from the EU. The transition period is ending on 31 December and there will be no ...
DELAY IMPLEMENTATION OF IR35 LEGISLATION REFORM UNTIL COVID-19 IS RESOLVED
Freelancers play a vital role in the UK economy and are the changing face of work. This petition requests the Government to delay the implementation of the upcoming IR35 legislation until COVID-19 i ...
FINANCIAL SUPPORT FOR SELF-EMPLOYED PEOPLE TO INCREASE
Chancellor Rishi Sunak this morning said that self-employed people would be given extra support due to the onset of a new national lockdown. Speaking to the BBC, he said that the cap on the current gr ...
FURLOUGH SCHEME EXTENDED AND FURTHER ECONOMIC SUPPORT ANNOUNCED
The Coronavirus Job Retention Scheme has been extended for a month with employees receiving 80% of their current salary for hours not worked and further economic support announced. People and business ...
SITES TO STAY OPEN AS SECOND LOCKDOWN BEGINS IN ENGLAND NEXT WEEK
New measures will remain in place until 2 December Construction sites will be able to stay open, as the prime minister this evening (31 October) confirmed a second lockdown in England will begin th ...