HMRC LOOSES IR35 CASE ALONG WITH INDUSTRY CONFIDENCE

blog header image

Posted : 29 May 2018 at 11:48:08
Category: Payroll News

Share this article

A Capita contractor has overturned an IR35 case against HMRC in a victory that will surely spark questions as to whether recruiters can trust the Government  over this much-contested tax reform.


In the First-Tier Tribunal Chamber IR35 case (Jensal Software Limited v Revenue & Customs) the court considered a working arrangement that took place between 28th May 2012 and 4th April 2013. The contract worker, who supplied his labour via a personal service company and through Capita, to the Department of Work and Pensions was believed by HMRC to be working inside IR35. However, contrary to the Government’s belief, a Judge found that the worker’s contract belonged outside of IR35 – primarily due to the absence of a sufficient degree of control over his working methods.


In addition, the Judge disagreed with HMRC’s interpretation of mutuality of obligation and the right of substitution. Seb Maley, CEO of Qdos Contractor, the firm who represented the contractor worker in this case, commented that the ruling will have recruiters questioning the Government’s IR35 expertise. He said: "Right now, recruitment Agencies will quite rightly be wondering whether HMRC is capable of managing IR35 reform. After all, in the public sector, it is now the fee payer - often the agency - that will be held liable for any resulting fines.


“If HMRC can’t make the right calls, how are recruitment agencies and clients expected to?"


Dave Chaplin, CEO and Founder of ContractorCalculator also expressed his surprise at HMRC’s pursuit of the case: “With the evidence being so compelling for the contractor, including a perfectly valid right of substitution, a lack of control and insufficient mutuality of obligation, one must question why HMRC pursued this case at all. It was a complete waste of tax payers money and court time.”


Maley added: “Despite HMRC implementing and enforcing the rules, this verdict shows they can’t accurately assess a contractor’s IR35 status. The Government is serious about clamping down on what they believe to be non-compliance, but worryingly, can’t recognise whether a contractor belongs inside or outside IR35. “That The individual was working on a Government project simply adds to the irony. This case is further proof that IR35 needs simplifying, and HMRC must rethink its IR35 strategy completely. Clearly, this is no time to extend public sector changes to the private sector.”


This isn’t the first time a contractor has successfully overturned a case against the Government. In March, a contractor won a case against HMRC. Again, the case relied on whether the worker had control and access to employment benefits. As the contract worker had limited control and no employment benefits, the tribunal found that the contract was not caught by IR35. Previously, HMRC have admitted that they hold no detailed information on the accuracy of the self-assessment tool which contractors use to make a decision if they are inside or outside of IR35.


SOURCE: Recruitment Grapevine

LATEST SIMILAR NEWS

IPSE: END OF BARCLAYS CONTRACTING IS “A TASTE OF THE IR35 CHAOS TO COME”
Posted on: 11 Oct 2019 at 13:05:46
Barclays’s announcement that it is calling time on off-payroll contracting is a sign of the damage the changes to IR35 will do, IPSE (the Association of Independent Professionals and the Self-Employed) has warned.The statement comes after Barclays announced it is ending off-payroll working entirely...
IR35 CHANGES: WHAT YOU NEED TO KNOW
Posted on: 08 Oct 2019 at 14:36:17
The eagerly awaited IR35 off-payroll draft legislation was published by the UK Government in mid-July, extending the public sector IR35 changes to large and medium-sized businesses in the private sector.Despite speculation, the draft legislation unfortunately keeps the government on course for imple...
IR35 BLAME GAME: BARCLAYS TO HALT OFF-PAYROLL CONTRACTORS, GOES DIRECTLY TO PAYE
Posted on: 08 Oct 2019 at 14:28:49
No bailout for tech freelancers. Bank moves to avoid potential liability for tax, NI contributionsUK bank Barclays is to call time on all off-payroll working and shift its entire contractor base to the Pay As You Earn (PAYE) system to swerve potential financial implications of private-sector IR35 le...
LENDY CO-FOUNDER LIAM BROOKE QUITS ROLE AT LENDER COPIOUS CAPITAL, LEAVING JUST ONE PERSON IN CHARGE
Posted on: 26 Sep 2019 at 11:00:02
One of the founders of Lendy has quit his role at wage advance company Copious Capital just one month after the collapse of the peer-to-peer (P2P) lender.The company, which trades under the name Pay Me Today, was set up in May last year, twelve months before Lendy fell into administration,...
WHEN THINGS GO WRONG WHEN USING THE WRONG PAYROLL PROVIDER
Posted on: 25 Sep 2019 at 10:41:16
Blakely v On-Site Recruitment Solutions Ltd & Heritage Solutions Ltd (Debarred) UKEAT/0134/17/DADate published: 26/01/2018Appeal against a finding that the Claimant was neither a worker nor an employee of the First Respondent. Appeal allowed and remitted to a fresh Tribunal.The First Respondent,...
IS A SELF-EMPLOYED PENSIONS CRISIS LOOMING?
Posted on: 18 Sep 2019 at 08:08:28
Government urged to “act now” over self-employed pensions “time bomb”On Pensions Awareness Day (15th September), IPSE, The Association of Independent Professionals and the Self-Employed, warned that without urgent change, 3.3million solo workers could be left without a pension in the next 10 years.&...