HMRC published new payroll guidance on 19 November 2026 to help employers prevent payroll errors and PAYE RTI disputed charges. An RTI disputed charge arises when the PAYE amount an employer believes it owes differs from the amount shown on HMRC’s systems, creating either a credit or a debit on the employer account. For construction, recruitment and labour-supply businesses, the control is immediate: make payroll inputs, RTI submissions and payment evidence traceable before an unexplained balance becomes a cash-flow or workforce problem.
In Issue 149 of Agent Update, HMRC announced GfC22: Help to prevent payroll errors and PAYE RTI disputed charges. HMRC says the guidance is for employers and anyone processing payroll for them, and may also help tax agents and professional bodies. It explains common errors, how to avoid them and what to do when a mistake is found.
The commercial point is not that every payroll difference is misconduct. It is that a disputed charge becomes much harder and more expensive to resolve when the business cannot quickly reconcile its payroll data to what was sent through RTI and what reached the employer account.
A debit on the employer account can trigger urgent investigation, payment uncertainty and time-consuming rework. In a labour-intensive business, that pressure can land alongside weekly pay runs, agency invoices and site mobilisation. If ownership is unclear between the employer, payroll bureau and labour supplier, fixing the record takes longer and management loses time to reconstruction rather than delivery.
The strongest control is an evidence chain: approved worker and starter data; contract and rate change authorisation; timesheet and absence record; payroll calculation; RTI submission confirmation; payment file; and reconciliation to HMRC’s account. A payroll report that cannot be traced back to its source inputs is not a reliable defence to a discrepancy.
Payroll errors are not only an employer-account issue. A wrong starter record, tax code, hours input or leaving date can mean a worker is paid incorrectly, sees an unexplained deduction, or has to wait while a correction is made. Contractors and agencies also need clean records where PAYE, CIS or mixed workforce arrangements interact.
Workers should receive a clear payslip and have a prompt route to raise a query. Businesses should preserve the original evidence and correction trail rather than overwrite records without explanation. That protects the worker’s confidence and gives the employer a better basis for correcting RTI data accurately.
Use HMRC’s new GfC22 as a control test, not a document to file away:
1. Assign ownership for payroll inputs, RTI submission, HMRC-account reconciliation and error escalation.<br>2. Reconcile every run: approved changes, gross-to-net calculation, RTI output, payment file and HMRC account should agree.<br>3. Test high-risk changes: new starters, leavers, late timesheets, back-pay, variable pay and tax-code changes need evidence before submission.<br>4. Protect the correction trail: record what was wrong, the source evidence, the correction, who approved it and how the worker was told.<br>5. Escalate unexplained balances early: do not wait for several pay periods to pass before investigating a debit or credit.
For contractors using CIS alongside PAYE, keep the two processes distinct but reconciled to the correct engagement route. A deduction statement or payslip is evidence; it is not a substitute for checking that the underlying worker and contract data is right.
Genius helps businesses make payroll, CIS and labour-supply-chain controls practical. We can review RTI reconciliation, payroll input ownership, error handling and the evidence trail across employees, agencies and contractors. The aim is to reduce disputed balances, protect worker pay and give directors a clear explanation when HMRC or a client asks.
If your payroll team cannot trace an HMRC balance back to a specific run and source record, speak to Genius before the next cycle.
Genius Tax & Money | 020 7700 2000 | hello@geniusmoney.co.uk | https://geniusmoney.co.uk
HMRC says it occurs where the PAYE amount an employer believes it owes differs from the amount shown on HMRC’s systems, resulting in a credit or debit on the employer account.
No. It is a signal to reconcile the evidence and investigate. The issue may be data, submission, timing or another error; do not assume the outcome before checking the records.
Raise it promptly with the employer or payroll contact and keep payslips, timesheets and any written pay explanation.
A bureau can process payroll, but the business still needs clear ownership, timely source records and approval of corrections.
Yes. We help businesses map the correct route, reconcile records and build a usable audit trail.