LATEST IR35 FORUM MINUTES CONFIRM HMRC PLANS TO ATTEMPT TO FIX CEST

blog header image

Posted : 09 Nov 2018 at 14:28:53
Category: News

Share this article

HMRC has confirmed its plans to attempt to fix its flawed Check Employment Status for Tax (CEST) tool with the publication of the latest IR35 Forum minutes.

CEST and mutuality of obligation (MOO) were the key points of discussion during the meeting, held on 30 August 2018. The taxman also announced plans to produce a revised note on MOO and to consider providing additional guidance on completion of CEST.

HMRC stated that it was already looking into ways to improve CEST ‘as part of normal good practice’ and promised to work with stakeholders to better understand numerous concerns regarding the tool raised in responses to the Off-Payroll working in the private sector consultation.

CEST and MOO prove key points of contention for Forum members

Central to CEST’s failings is its failure to consider MOO under the taxman’s assumption that MOO is present in all contractual engagements. HMRC’s flawed interpretation has been rejected by IR35 Forum members and disproven in multiple recent tribunal cases. Unsurprisingly, it was among a number of concerns shared by Forum members, which also included:

CEST’s failure to handle cases where an individual has a range of engagements

That CEST should reflect the outcome of litigation since March 2017

That CEST isn’t suitable for the larger and more diverse private sector.

In addition to attempting to fix CEST, HMRC announced it would consider redrafting and expanding its position paper on MOO to cover what the taxman described as ‘competing arguments’ about its significance where there is a succession of short engagements.

HMRC also addressed the issue of non-compliance with Off-Payroll among agencies and umbrella companies. It concluded that non-compliance is largely deliberate rather than a result of a lack of awareness. As a result, it rejected proposals to publish best practice standards, which it claimed would likely be ignored and has instead published a Spotlight article on the issue.

Striving for simplicity won’t help CEST

While the contract sector welcomes HMRC’s acknowledgement of CEST’s shortcomings, its comments concerning its desired outcome for the tool suggest that it is still failing to take on the advice of experts. The Forum minutes state:

‘HMRC commented that there needs to be a balance between a tool that is simple and straightforward with a relatively small number of questions, suitable for the majority of customers, and attempting to cover every eventuality.’

“As long as HMRC continues to prioritise simplicity over accuracy, CEST will continue to fall a long way short of what is required of an employment status tool. This has been our message all along to HMRC,” comments Chaplin.

“You can’t reduce decades of employment case law to a few simple questions, which is why CEST has been roundly rejected by experts and why it has continually been shown to provide incorrect outcomes.”

Chaplin concludes: “Having announced plans to offload the responsibility for IR35 compliance onto UK firms, HMRC should feel an obligation to mitigate the administrative burden that it imposes. But continuing to tweak a tool that is ideologically flawed is only going to give rise to further issues.”


Original source contractorcalculator.co.uk

LATEST SIMILAR NEWS

GALLIFORD TRY CHIEF QUITS TO JOIN CREST NICHOLSON
Posted on: 26 Mar 2019 at 09:05:12
Truscott will take the helm in September, replacing Patrick Bergin, who has agreed to step down from the group chief executive role immediately.He starts on a salary of £650,000, pension contribution of 10% of salary and a bonus opportunity of 125%.The move has triggered a board reshuffle at Ga...
CONSULTATION MARCH 2019 OFF-PAYROLL WORKING RULES FROM APRIL 2020
Posted on: 18 Mar 2019 at 09:22:35
On 5th March 2019, HMRC published the consultation document ‘Off-payroll working rules from April 2020’. The consultation seeks to refine the operation of the off-payroll rules prior to implementation into the private sector from April 2020.KEY POINTS FROM THE CONSULTATIONNo groundbreaking changes w...
INTERSERVE GOES INTO ADMINISTRATION AFTER RESCUE DEAL REJECTED
Posted on: 18 Mar 2019 at 09:12:14
Interserve has government contracts to clean hospitals. Photograph: Christopher Thomond/The GuardianThe government contractor Interserve has gone into administration after its largest shareholder, the US hedge fund Coltrane, led a rebellion against financial rescue plans drawn up by the co...
HMRC LOSES £100K IR35 ENQUIRY IN ANOTHER STORY OF TAXMAN’S APPROACH TO COMPLIANCE
Posted on: 20 Feb 2019 at 10:18:35
With many of us looking ahead to what HMRC has in store for the roll-out of private sector IR35 reform next year, you could be forgiven for not noticing the current behaviour of the taxman. But it was again brought into sharp focus this month in a disturbing case of a needless IR35 enquiry, del...
BILLIONAIRE KEN GRIFFIN PAYS RECORD $238M FOR MANHATTAN APARTMENT
Posted on: 19 Feb 2019 at 17:15:11
A Manhattan apartment has just been sold for $238m (£183m) - the most expensive home ever sold in the US.The property, in the luxury 220 Central Park South building, has four floors and - naturally - overlooks the famous New York park.The buyer is billionaire Ken Griffin, founder of the hedge fund C...
NOT ENOUGH NEW HOMES
Posted on: 19 Feb 2019 at 17:05:37
A report from the National Audit Office shows that the government is unlikely to meet its plan for 300,000 new homes a year by the mid 2020s.Aileen Murphie of the NAO told BBC Radio 4's Today Programme that the target will not be met unless the "planning system works better than it is at the moment"...