HMRC LOSES £100K IR35 ENQUIRY IN ANOTHER STORY OF TAXMAN’S APPROACH TO COMPLIANCE

blog header image

Posted : 20 Feb 2019 at 10:18:35
Category: News

Share this article

With many of us looking ahead to what HMRC has in store for the roll-out of private sector IR35 reform next year, you could be forgiven for not noticing the current behaviour of the taxman. But it was again brought into sharp focus this month in a disturbing case of a needless IR35 enquiry, delay, lack of transparency and indifference to the impact of the contractors involved. 

Last week, Qdos received the welcome news that we had successfully shut down a year-long IR35 enquiry where the tax liabilities would have amounted to more than £100,000 for two contractors, both of whom are directors for the limited company that was under investigation.

 The outcome was a huge relief for the contractors of course, whose company was protected with tax enquiry insurance. And it was another win for Qdos. But there is a bigger story behind this that’s worth exploring. The inadequacies the case brought to light and latest defeat inflicted on HMRC should be of concern to all of us.

 The length of time it took the taxman to accept reality is another indication of HMRC’s lack of care for contractors’ well-being.

We are left asking a number of questions about the case. Why, when the right of substitution was exercised regularly by the contractors on the two projects being investigated, did it take HMRC more than a year to accept that they both belonged outside the scope of IR35? The length of time it took the taxman to accept reality is another indication of HMRC’s lack of care for contractors’ well-being. There appears to be a tendency to draw things out for the long-term.

 So why did HMRC, that has shown so much faith in its IR35 technology, choose not to use it to assess the status of these two individuals?

Of course, demonstrating substitution alone doesn’t always mean a contract should sit outside IR35, but when assessed by CEST - the taxman’s very own IR35 tool - it does. Put any engagement with a genuine right of substitution through CEST and it will deliver an outside IR35 verdict. So why did HMRC, that has shown so much faith in its IR35 technology, choose not to use it to assess the status of these two individuals? Was this deliberate or just another sign of the internal chaos and disorganisation at HMRC? I’ll let you decide, but whatever your opinion, it doesn’t look good for the taxman.

 Furthermore, in our team’s expert opinion, control was not exercised by either end-clients. By all criteria, it was a fairly cut and dried case, but HMRC seemed determined to go the distance in what wasn’t your typical IR35 enquiry.

 This case was slightly unusual, and not just for the fact that it involved two contractors working through one limited company. HMRC initially opened a Corporation Tax enquiry in 2017 before deciding to pursue the business in January 2018 for IR35 liabilities. Was this merely a coincidence? We can’t rule it out, but the chances of this do seem slim. And so we’re led to wonder whether this was a move to target the company one way or another based on information sharing between departments. As always, HMRC will keep its cards close to its chest, but for all we know this could be a sign of things to come.

In addition to HMRC finally accepting that IR35 did not apply (I hasten to add they didn’t specifically disclose why), there was one other positive to take from this particular case. The two private sector end-clients were very supportive of the contractors’ outside IR35 status, emphasising just how important it is that contractors, clients and when involved, agencies, are joined up in their thinking.

IR35 reform can be managed but accurate assessments must be prioritised over risk-averse decisions. 

This part of the story at least bodes well for contractors, many of whom quite understandably have fears about the private sector’s readiness for next April, when medium and large engagers become responsible for administering IR35. It shows that some private sector companies are ready to contribute to the discussion, take the matter seriously and will support contractors’ outside IR35 status. We’re working hard to make sure this message carries through when the liability shifts to these engagers next year - IR35 reform can be managed but accurate assessments must be prioritised over risk-averse decisions.

 HMRC also has a responsibility to play its part in all of this too. After suffering yet another loss, the taxman needs to rethink the way it enforces IR35 - because right now, its current strategy clearly isn’t working.


If you are engaging Self -Employed contractors and are really not sure how to confirm or check the status, especially with the current issues being highlighted with the HMRC CEST system, please get in touch with one of our Service Consultants on 0207 700 2000.


https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/hmrc-loses-100k-ir35-enquiry-another-story-taxmans-shambolic-maley/

LATEST SIMILAR NEWS

JAPAN’S BIGGEST HOUSE BUILDER MOVES INTO UK MARKET
Posted on: 14 May 2019 at 08:36:03
Japan’s biggest house builder has struck a £90m deal with Homes England and Urban Splash to deliver thousands of new properties across England.Sekisui House are pioneers of modern methods of construction and will bring their techniques to the UK.The deal includes new investment of £55m into regenera...
FIT-OUT DIRECTORS BANNED FOLLOWING CARTEL PROBE
Posted on: 13 May 2019 at 08:09:59
Three former directors of office fit-out companies have been disqualified for their involvement in illegal cartel behaviour.The bans follow a Competition and Markets Authority investigation which led to five firms being fined £7m in March.Fourfront, Loop, Coriolis, ThirdWay and Oakley were fine...
CONSTRUCTION WORKERS RATE MACE TO BE THE BEST OF THE BUNCH
Posted on: 08 May 2019 at 13:32:21
An analysis of employees’ ratings of the companies for which they work shows Mace to be the UK’s highest rated construction company.Mace has toppled Sir Robert McAlpine from the top spotGlassdoor.co.uk provides a forum and a template for workers to rate their employers. While the findings do no...
LAKEHOUSE WENT UNDER OWING SUBCONTRACTORS MORE THAN £9M
Posted on: 07 May 2019 at 09:58:47
Lakehouse Contracts went down owing more than £9m to subcontractors and suppliers.An administrator’s report seen by the Enquirer reveals the full extent of the cash black hole at the company which went down in March.Hundreds of firms are owed money by Lakehouse Contracts which crashed foll...
HSBC TELLS CONTRACTORS 'QUIT OR GO PERM' BEFORE IR35 REFORMS BITE
Posted on: 01 May 2019 at 15:38:54
HSBC will cease engaging limited company contractors from this September, saving itself the job of having to assess them under a new IR35 from April 2020, ContractorUK has learnt.The bank has told all PSC contractors at key units like HSBC Digital that after one further contract extension, they...
GALLIFORD TRY PUTS 350 CONSTRUCTION JOBS AT RISK
Posted on: 01 May 2019 at 10:37:17
Galliford Try is preparing to swing the axe at the construction division after telling staff yesterday that 350 jobs are at risk.Galliford Try is counting the cost of undertaking major infrastructure projects in Scotland like the Queensferry Crossing and Aberdeen BypassA wave of job cuts is planned...