In the world of self-employment and contracting, few regulations have caused as much confusion as IR35. Introduced by HMRC to tackle "disguised employment," IR35 is meant to ensure that individuals who work like employees but operate through limited companies pay similar taxes to regular employees. But when it comes to small and medium-sized construction businesses, the impact of IR35 is often misunderstood - and in many cases, it simply doesn't apply.
Understanding IR35:
IR35 (officially known as the Intermediaries Legislation) applies when a contractor provides services to a client through an intermediary, usually a limited company or personal service company (PSC), but would be considered an employee if the intermediary were removed.
Key factors that determine whether IR35 applies include: - Control: Does the client control what, how, and when the contractor does their work? - Substitution: Can the contractor send someone else to do the work? - Mutuality of Obligation: Is the client obliged to offer work, and is the contractor obliged to accept it?
Why IR35 Doesn't Usually Apply to SME Construction Businesses
IR35 mainly targets "disguised employees" - individuals working like full-time staff but avoiding PAYE taxes through their limited company setup. However, most small and medium-sized construction businesses don't fit this profile. Here's why:
1. Genuine Business-to-Business Relationships SME construction firms often work on a project-by-project basis and deliver services to multiple clients, each with its own contract, scope, and timescales. These are genuine business transactions, not attempts to disguise employment.
2. Labour-Only Subcontractors Are Often CIS Registered Construction Industry Scheme (CIS) contractors already operate under a separate HMRC regime, where tax is deducted at source. CIS applies to subcontractors rather than employees, and it's already designed to prevent tax avoidance in construction. If you're paid under CIS, IR35 is usually irrelevant.
3. IR35 Reforms Target Medium and Large Clients Since the 2021 reform to off-payroll working rules, it's the responsibility of medium and large private sector clients to determine a contractor's IR35 status. But small companies are exempt from this obligation - and that includes most SME construction firms.
To qualify as a "small" company (and therefore be exempt from the IR35 client responsibilities), the business must meet two of the following: - Annual turnover of £15 million or less - Balance sheet total of £7.5 million or less - Fewer than 50 employees
In this scenario, IR35 remains the responsibility of the contractor, not the client. And for most self-employed tradespeople or subcontractors, their working arrangements are clearly outside IR35.
4. Subcontractor Independence Tradespeople in construction typically provide their own tools, manage their own schedules, and sometimes bring in additional labour. These are classic signs of self-employment - and strong indicators that IR35 doesn't apply.
Final Word
IR35 was designed to catch white-collar professionals masquerading as businesses to avoid tax, not bricklayers, electricians, or plumbers running legitimate trade operations. For most SME construction businesses, especially those operating under CIS or working with genuinely self-employed subcontractors, IR35 is not something to lose sleep over.
However, it's always wise to keep documentation in order, have clear contracts, and seek professional advice if in doubt. But in general, SME construction firms can rest easy knowing that IR35 likely doesn't apply to them.
For more information and how you can protect yourself against investigation, please visit https://geniusmoney.co.uk/
Free business health check - https://geniusmoney.co.uk/legislation/business-healthcheck
